Shop › Key Lime Pie Image 1 of 2 Image 2 of 2 Key Lime Pie $40.00 10” Whole Pie Made w/ Real Key Limes w/ Graham Cracker Crust & Whipped Cream. Named Best In Tampa Bay by Creative Loafing! Add To Cart Added! 10” Whole Pie Made w/ Real Key Limes w/ Graham Cracker Crust & Whipped Cream. Named Best In Tampa Bay by Creative Loafing! You Might Also Like Quick View Florida Stone Crabs $70.00 Quick View Cheek Rub $13.00 Quick View Smoked Fish Dip $24.00 Quick View Deviled Eggs $24.00 Quick View Classic Shrimp Cocktail $29.00